I ended up buying Infrared Matte, also known as True Red, by Smashbox. It was only $19 at Sephora which is a good price for a very good lipstick. The lipsticks have vitamin C and E. The difference between matte and creme or lacquered lipstick is that matte does not look glossy at all. I like matte lipstick because it doesn't rub off as easy, smudge or get on your teeth. I also think if you're getting glossy looking lipstick you might as well spring for lip gloss. Anyways, the color is phenomenal and it's long lasting. I love it. Sephora is now my go-to make up store.
Product: Be Legendary Lipstick by Smashbox